Prince of the Church Assembly #2534 (1998-2004)
James Cardinal Hickey Prince of the Church Assembly #2534 (2004-2015)
James Cardinal Hickey Assembly #2534 (2015-Present)
| Faithful Navigator | Years of Service |
| SK Charles H. Gallina | 1998-2000 |
| SK Robert S. Fuller | 2000-2002 |
| SK Franklin F.B. Woodbury | 2002-2004 |
| SK Lawrence E. Laurion | 2004-2005 |
| SK Larry L. Owens | 2005-2006 |
| SK Anthony I. Colbert | 2006-2008 |
| †SK Richard P. Branson | 2008-2010 |
| SK Nicholas Scopellite | 2010-2011 |
| SK Timothy M. Saccoccia | 2011-2013 |
| SK Otto E. Heck | 2013-2015 |
| SK Edward J. Mays | 2015-2017 |
